Frequently Asked Questions on Maintenance and Alimony:
Q1: What is maintenance in the context of Indian law?
Answer:
Maintenance in Indian law refers to the financial support provided by one spouse to another during or after a legal separation or divorce. It is not defined explicitly in the marriage laws of any of the religious communities in India. Still, it is a measure to ensure that a spouse who cannot support themselves financially is provided for. The entitlement to claim maintenance is based on the assumption that the claimant does not have sufficient means for self-support.
Q2: Who can claim maintenance?
Answer:
Typically, any spouse who does not have adequate means to maintain themselves can claim maintenance. This includes neglected wives, children, and parents. The provisions are designed to prevent these dependents from falling into poverty which could lead to social issues.
Q3: What factors are considered by the court when determining the amount of maintenance?
Answer:
Courts consider several factors including:
· The status and lifestyle of the parties.
· The reasonable wants of the claimant.
· The independent income and property of the claimant.
· The number of people the non-applicant (usually the husband) must maintain.
· The non-applicant’s earning capacity and liabilities.
· Provisions for basic needs such as food, clothing, shelter, education, and medical needs of the applicant.
Q4: What is interim maintenance?
Answer:
Interim maintenance is temporary financial support given to a spouse during the pendency of divorce proceedings. It aims to ensure that the spouse claiming maintenance can maintain a similar standard of living as enjoyed during the marriage. This support continues until the final decision is made on the divorce case.
Q5: Under what circumstances can maintenance be denied?
Answer: 1. Maintenance can be denied or cancelled under several conditions, such as:
2. If the claimant is highly qualified or previously working and is capable of supporting themselves.
3. If the claimant is living in adultery.
4. If there is proof of a void or invalid marriage.
5. Non-disclosure of essential facts by the claimant.
6. Resumption of cohabitation between the spouses.
Q6: Can a woman in a live-in relationship claim maintenance?
Answer:
Yes, women in live-in relationships can claim maintenance under certain conditions. The Supreme Court of India has recognized long-term live-in relationships as equivalent to marriage under certain conditions, and children born out of such relationships are considered legitimate. Women in such relationships can claim maintenance similar to wives if they can prove that they have lived together in a relationship similar to marriage.
Q7: How is the amount of alimony determined in India?
Answer:
Alimony, unlike Maintenance which can be interim or for the child and parents as well, specifically refers to the financial support one spouse pays to another post-divorce. The amount is determined by the court based on various factors including the spouse's own income and earning potential, the lifestyle during the marriage, the duration of the marriage, and the health and age of both parties. The courts also consider the impact of other responsibilities like child support on the paying spouse.
Q8: Can a husband claim maintenance from his wife?
Answer:
Yes, under Indian law, husbands can also claim maintenance from their wives if they prove that they do not have sufficient means to support themselves and that the wife has enough means to provide support. This is applicable under certain personal laws and the Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, which is gender-neutral.
Q9: What happens if the party ordered to pay maintenance fails to comply?
Answer:
If a party fails to comply with a maintenance order, the court can take various measures to enforce the order. This includes garnishing the wages of the non-complying party, attaching their bank accounts or other property, or even sentencing them to imprisonment for contempt of court.
Q10: Can maintenance be modified after the final order?
Ansewer:
Yes, maintenance orders are not necessarily permanent and can be modified based on a change in circumstances. If either party has a significant change in their financial situation or other relevant changes, they can petition the court to increase, decrease, or terminate the maintenance payments.
Comments